We recently stayed at the Warren Street Hotel and had a wonderful experience as we celebrated our first wedding anniversary.
Service: From the moment we arrived, the staff stood out. Everyone we met during check-in was warm, professional, and genuinely helpful. The housekeeping team also deserves special mention. Every time we returned to the room, it felt spotless, with incredible attention to detail, especially in the bathroom.
Dining: Breakfast each morning was excellent - simple dishes prepared very well, and even the lattes were delicious (a rarity in many hotels). We also enjoyed happy hour at the bar, where the cocktails were well made and the sliders were cooked to perfection.
Room & Amenities: The room was spacious, stylish, and thoughtfully designed. It had a boutique vibe - unique, curated décor that felt intentional rather than generic. The oversized tub with its own TV was a highlight, and Apple TV in the room made streaming movies easy and reliable. WiFi was strong throughout our stay with no issues.
Location: We didn’t explore too much on foot, but the area seemed nice, with a few good coffee and food spots nearby. Subway and restaurants were convenient to reach, making it an easy place to stay for getting around New York.
Noise: We stayed on the 4th floor and were pleasantly surprised at how quiet it was. We didn’t notice any street noise or sound from neighboring rooms during the entire stay.
Check-In/Out: Both check-in and check-out were smooth and quick, with no hiccups or delays.
Drawbacks: The only real downsides were the pillows and the lack of an on-site gym. The bed itself was firm (which we prefer), but the pillows deflated too easily and didn’t provide much support, especially as side sleepers. A firmer or thicker alternative pillow option would go a long way. As for the gym, we knew before booking that it wasn’t on-site, but walking a few blocks and going through a separate check-in process made it less convenient.
Value: We booked at a good rate, though we’ve noticed prices climbing for future stays. While the experience is excellent, it’s approaching the upper end of value given the amount of competition in New York.
Overall: Despite a couple of small drawbacks, we had a fantastic stay and would happily return. The attentive staff, excellent dining, quiet rooms, and boutique feel made it a memorable experience.